Western astrology books
Alan Leo's How to Judge a Nativity: 22 Chapters
Published 2026-11-05 | Live Pandit Ji
Alan Leo planned his textbooks as a staircase, one volume to each stage of study, and How to Judge a Nativity is the step for reading a chart once it has been drawn. The copy read here is the 1928 printing, the fourth edition, issued from the Modern Astrology Office in London. This page goes through it from the title page to the advertisements at the back: what the book says about its own author, the seven text books of the series, all twenty-two chapters with the pages each fills, the 100 short aphorisms that close it, and the points where Leo’s English method and the jyotish texts on this site go separate ways. His rules are described, not applied to anyone, and nothing below tests them.
What the Book Says About Alan Leo
The prefaces carry his signature, and they are the only account of him that the printing gives. The first one explains the plan of the series: the opening volume, Astrology for All, dealt with the signs and planets, the second with casting the chart, and this third with judging it, so that each department of study gets its own book. It also makes a claim of originality. “What is here written has not been copied from other books”, Leo writes, presenting the work as the fruit of his own thought and practice, and he says it strikes the note of what he calls the New Astrology, whose foundation, in his words, was already laid by the establishment of Modern Astrology, the name also borne by the magazine whose office published the book.
The preface’s language is devotional as much as technical. The same preface makes astrology one of seven keys to the door of an inner temple, and the introduction argues at length for reincarnation, treating each chart as a step in the long growth of a soul. A later volume of the series, Esoteric Astrology, was given over entirely to that side of his thinking.
Two facts about him come from the back pages, both without dates. The list there advertises The Life and Work of Alan Leo, by Bessie Leo, and it calls a booklet titled Jupiter: the Preserver “Alan Leo’s last book”. Since the printing gives no year of birth or death, this page gives none either.
The 7 Text Books of the Series
The title page names the book volume III of the “Astrology for All” Series and notes that it was formerly issued as How to Judge a Nativity, Part I. The publisher’s list at the end prints the text books together at one price, in this order, each with a line of description, quoted here as printed:
| No. | Text book | The 1928 list describes it as |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Astrology for All | Requires no knowledge of Mathematics. |
| 2 | Casting the Horoscope | “The Astrologer’s Baedeker.” |
| 3 | How to Judge a Nativity | Complete Rules for Judgments. |
| 4 | The Art of Synthesis | Showing the relation between Planets and Consciousness. |
| 5 | The Progressed Horoscope | An exhaustive treatise on both the Primary and Secondary systems of Directing. |
| 6 | The Key to your own Nativity | How to read your own Horoscope. |
| 7 | Esoteric Astrology | A new presentation of Astrology showing the inner meaning. |
How to Judge a Nativity stands third on the list, which agrees with the volume number on its title page. Below the text books come a reference index to the whole series and fifteen pocket manuals, smaller and cheaper books on single topics, which this page does not go into. Inside the text Leo keeps pointing along the shelf: chapter IV begins from the list of aspects already given in Astrology for All, a footnote in chapter II sends the reckoning of the houses to Casting the Horoscope, and a note in chapter XXII leaves the question of heredity to The Art of Synthesis.
All 22 Chapters and Their Pages
The titles follow the book’s detailed table of contents, tidied where the scan’s machine reading garbled a letter or a numeral, and each opening page is taken from the folio printed near its heading. A chapter’s length is counted up to the next chapter’s first page, or for the last one, to page 331, where the aphorisms begin.
| Ch. | Title | From page | Pages | Contents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | The Twelve Houses of the Horoscope | 1 | 10 | The circle of houses drawn from the turning of the earth, the four angles and quarters of the day, and the three angles named with the Sanskrit words kama, kama-manas and manas |
| II | The Twelve Signs of the Zodiac | 11 | 16 | The signs as against the constellations, the triplicities and qualities, the polarities, and a table of what each sign stands for |
| III | The Luminaries and the Planets | 27 | 12 | The sign rulers, then the planets one by one, each paired with a sense or a faculty, Uranus and Neptune included |
| IV | The Aspects | 39 | 29 | Conjunction, parallel, trine, square and the minor aspects, why the book counts the square as evil and the trine as good, and the orbs |
| V | The Three Centres: Sun, Moon and Ascendant | 68 | 22 | The Sun, the Moon and the ascendant weighed against one another, then the Sun and the Moon through the twelve signs |
| VI | The Ascendant or Rising Sign. The First House | 90 | 39 | Each sign on the ascendant, its three decanates and their part rulers, and planets rising |
| VII | The Ruling Planet | 129 | 9 | How to pick the ruling planet, worked on the birth data of public figures of the day, and its place by sign and house |
| VIII | Health and the Hyleg. Length of Life and the Apheta | 138 | 13 | The hyleg, the apheta and the anareta, and the reading of illness and the span of life (subject only) |
| IX | The Second House. Wealth and Finance, and Hereditary Position | 151 | 7 | Planets and money, and the Part of Fortune |
| X | The Third House. Brethren and Relatives, Short Journeys, the Mind | 158 | 6 | Planets in the third house and the sign on its cusp, read for kin, short journeys and the mind |
| XI | The Fourth House. Environment, Home, Parents; the End of Life | 164 | 8 | Home, parents and the close of life, with an illustrative chart (subject only) |
| XII | The Fifth House. Children, Enterprise, Speculations, Gains, Love Affairs | 172 | 6 | Children, speculation and love affairs (subject only) |
| XIII | The Sixth House. Sickness, Servants, Work | 178 | 6 | Sickness, servants and work (subject only) |
| XIV | The Seventh House. Marriage, Partnerships, Enemies | 184 | 11 | Marriage, partnership and open enemies, with separate sections for women's and men's charts (subject only) |
| XV | The Eighth House. Death, and the Dream Consciousness | 195 | 7 | Death and the dream state, with an illustrative chart (subject only) |
| XVI | The Ninth House. Philosophy and Travel | 202 | 5 | The higher mind, religion and long journeys |
| XVII | The Mid-Heaven or Tenth House | 207 | 10 | Honour, reputation and profession, the signs that hold most of the planets, and Mercury's aspects as signs of employment |
| XVIII | The Eleventh House. Friends, Hopes and Wishes | 217 | 9 | Friends and hopes, comparing two charts for friendship, and seven types of people |
| XIX | The Twelfth House. The 'House of Self-Undoing' | 226 | 6 | The twelfth house, then the angular, succedent and cadent houses compared and a table of their relative value |
| XX | A Compendium of Planetary Positions and Aspects | 232 | 55 | Each planet from Neptune inward by sign and by aspect to the others, a book of delineations within the book |
| XXI | Concluding Remarks on Judgment | 287 | 7 | The decanates, the polarities of the Sun and the Moon, and the individual and personal sides of character |
| XXII | A Simple Way of Reading Horoscopes | 294 | 37 | A step-by-step scheme for setting out a reading, illustrated on the nativity of King Edward VII |
The plan is easy to see in the table. Chapters I to V lay out the materials: houses, signs, planets, aspects, and the three centres of Sun, Moon and ascendant. From chapter VI the book walks round the chart, giving the first house a chapter and then, from chapter IX to chapter XIX, the second to the twelfth one each, in order. Only chapters VII and VIII, on the ruling planet and on health, interrupt the walk, both placed straight after the ascendant.
The heaviest single chapter is chapter XX, the compendium, at 55 pages, about 17 per cent of the 330 pages from chapter I to the end of chapter XXII. It runs through each planet by sign and by aspect, from Neptune inward, and works as a reference list of delineations; none of them is reproduced here. Next in size comes chapter VI, the rising sign, at 39 pages. Chapter XXII closes the teaching with a scheme for setting a reading out step by step, illustrated on the nativity of King Edward VII; the scheme’s headings are listed in the contents, and its judgments on the King are not repeated on this page.
Set that plan beside Varahamihira’s Brihat Jataka and the difference is one of architecture. The Sanskrit book handles the planets in the houses in a single chapter, number 20 of its 28, and gives its other chapters to subjects such as the dashas, the yogas and the planets in the signs. Leo gives twelve of his 22 chapters to the houses, one apiece, and reads every topic of a life through the house assigned to it.
Six Chapters Kept to Their Titles
Chapters VIII, XI, XII, XIII, XIV and XV take up health and the length of life, the close of life under the fourth house, children and speculation, sickness, the marriage partner and death. They appear in the table so the book’s plan is complete, but the site prints none of their rules or results: it does not pass on readings of health, death, children or a partner from a chart, whoever wrote them. The same goes for the separate rules chapter XIV gives for women’s and men’s charts, and for the birth data of public figures that chapter VII uses as worked examples.
The Centiloquy of 100 Aphorisms
The last pages, 331 to 336, hold what Leo calls a Centiloquy. His note borrows the name from the Centiloquies of Claudius Ptolemy and others, and says the aim is to fix the gist of the book in the student’s mind; every aphorism ends with the page where the fuller treatment sits, so the hundred also serve as an index. The numbering runs from I to C without a gap.
Two of them carry the frame of the whole method. Aphorism IX reads: “The influence of the Signs is greater than that of the Houses”. Aphorism X gives the image behind it: “The Houses are like transparent vessels, each having its own pattern; the Signs supply the contents of such vessels”, the same picture chapter II uses when it first sets houses and signs side by side. Many of the others repeat rules from the chapters named above by title only, and are left out for the same reason.
Where Leo’s Method Parts From Jyotish
The zodiac. A footnote in chapter II draws the line itself. Leo separates the signs from the star groups that share their names and writes: “The Hindus and some other oriental nations work by these constellations, but the western astrologer always calculates in terms of the signs”. His zodiac begins where the Sun crosses the equator going north, and he backs that with a passage from Ashmand’s translation of Ptolemy’s Tetrabiblos. That is the tropical zodiac. The site’s charts and tables are sidereal, and the gap between the two frames is explained on the ayanamsa page; every sign Leo names belongs to the tropical frame, so his sign rules cannot be laid over the site’s sidereal positions without first converting.
The houses. Opening chapter II, Leo looks back on chapter I and calls the houses “the twelve equal divisions of the circle of observation”; a footnote to the same sentence warns at once that the description needs qualifying and refers the reader to Casting the Horoscope. The working method shows up in chapter VI, where a footnote has the student take the sidereal time at birth and look up a table of houses to find where the first house gives way to the twelfth. A whole-sign chart, which needs only the rising sign, would not call for that step; the house systems page compares the main ways of drawing the twelve.
The ruling planet. Chapter VII opens by saying that “the ‘ruling planet’ is either the lord of the ascending sign, or else that planet which is strongest or most prominent in the horoscope”. It weighs planets rising and planets on the angles, and only where doubt remains does it settle on the lord of the rising sign. That is a looser idea than the one-line definition set out on the chart ruler page, which takes the ruler of the ascendant’s sign and nothing else, and the two should not be confused.
The planets. Chapter III pairs each planet with a sense or a faculty and keeps Uranus and Neptune in the scheme, and the compendium starts with Neptune. Jyotish counts nine grahas, none of them the outer planets, as the Harshal, Varun and Yam page explains.
The Part of Fortune. Chapter IX adds the ascendant’s longitude to the Moon’s and subtracts the Sun’s, counting in signs and degrees, and works one example: Sun Aquarius 18°04′, Moon Capricorn 26°04′, ascendant Gemini 20°29′. Ascendant plus Moon comes to a full circle and 16°33′ more; with the Sun taken away the Part falls at Taurus 28°29′, the figure the book prints, and the site’s code repeats the sum to the same result. The section offers that one formula for every birth and no separate version for a night birth, the practice set out on the Part of Fortune page; the wider family of such points is on the Hermetic lots page.
The decanates. Here the two traditions come close. For each third of a rising sign chapter VI names a part ruler, and for the four signs from Aries to Cancer the site’s code checked all twelve of those thirds against the Parashari drekkana, in which a sign’s thirds go to the sign itself, its fifth and its ninth. Every planet Leo names first is the lord of that drekkana sign; the only extra is in Gemini’s third decanate, where he writes “Saturn or Uranus”. The D3 drekkana page lists all of the drekkana lords, the Brihat Jataka page finds the same rule in Varahamihira’s first chapter, and the decan dates page shows when the Sun enters each third in both zodiacs. The other eight signs were not checked for this page.
Timing. This volume has no method for dating events. Leo’s position, stated in chapter III, is that the nativity must be fully understood before “directions” are read, and the series hands directions to its fifth text book, The Progressed Horoscope, which the list describes as covering both the primary and the secondary systems. The secondary system is the day-for-a-year count worked on the progressed Moon page. Jyotish dates the stretches of a life by dasha instead, a separate calculation that is not derived from progressions.
The Sanskrit words. Leo borrows Indian terms for his own scheme. Chapter I labels the first, tenth and seventh angles with kama, kama-manas and manas, and chapter II likens the cardinal, fixed and mutable signs to what it calls the Hindu rajas, tamas and sattva. These are his mappings, made in English for an English system; this page does not treat them as readings of any Sanskrit text.
A History in the Third Preface
For the third edition Leo added a short history of astrology, written, he says, for students who wanted the weight of tradition behind the subject. Its line on India goes back “three thousand one hundred and two years” before Christ and names the “Tirvalore Tables”. The year, 3102 BC, is the Kali Yuga epoch that the site’s Kali Samvat page takes from Burgess’s Surya Siddhanta. The preface uses it as evidence of how old astrology is; this page records the claim and leaves the history untested.
Next to the Site’s Other Western Pages
Leo wrote within a Western line that the site meets in several places. The sect page reads Ptolemy’s split of the planets into a day party and a night party, the Yavanajataka page follows Greek astrology into Sanskrit, and the pages linked above on houses, the chart ruler, the Part of Fortune and progressions each take one of these techniques and work it through with numbers.
Leo Starts From a Tropical Ascendant
Chapter VI begins with the sign on the ascendant, measured in the tropical zodiac. The ascendant calculator finds the sidereal rising sign for a birth date, time and listed city, and prints the tropical longitude beside it along with the ayanamsa it took away. Every 30 degrees of that tropical figure is one sign, counting from the start of Aries. The calculator offers no reading of either sign.
See Both Ascendants