Skip to main content
Live Pandit Ji
LIVE

book history

Who Wrote Lal Kitab? Roop Chand Joshi and 5 Editions

Published 2026-11-04 | Live Pandit Ji

Ask who wrote the Lal Kitab (लाल किताब, the “red book”) and the usual reply is one name: Pandit Roop Chand Joshi, of the village of Pharwala in Jalandhar district. That reply comes from somewhere, and so does a second name that the old title pages print instead. This page follows both, lists the five Urdu books that appeared between 1939 and 1952 with their years and sizes, and says what can fairly be called the original Lal Kitab today. It is a history of a book. No farman or remedy from it is repeated here, and none is said to work.

What Wikipedia Says About Roop Chand Joshi

English Wikipedia’s article on the Lal Kitab, read for this page on 4 November 2026, opens its authorship section with a caution: the author of the original verses, it says, is unknown or a matter of debate. In the same sentence it credits Pandit Roop Chand Joshi, 1898 to 1982, of Pharwala village in Jalandhar district of Punjab, then a province of British India, with the version available now, written over the years 1939 to 1952 in five volumes. It adds that some people regard him as the books’ originator too. The article gives no other detail of his life, and this page adds none.

The birth year rests on a Dainik Jagran report dated 19 January 2018, which the article cites and whose headline speaks of Joshi’s 121st birth anniversary. Counted in completed years, that number points to 1897; counted with the birth itself as the first, it points to 1898. Wikipedia prints 1898, and the page gives that year as Wikipedia gives it.

An archive.org uploader said much the same in 2010. The description of item LalKitab1941, the one Wikipedia cites as volume three, names Joshi with his village and district, calls the 1941 book the third of his five, and says that all five were written in Urdu.

The Name Printed on the Title Pages

The scans tell a less tidy story. On the printed title pages of the 1939, 1942 and 1952 books, read here as page images, the one person named is Sharma Girdhari Lal, described as living in Pharwala, post office Nurmahal, Jalandhar district. The 1939 and 1942 pages call him the printer and publisher, and the first of the three 1952 scans opens with his photograph under the word “publisher”. None of those pages names Pandit Roop Chand Joshi.

The name of Roop Chand Joshi does appear in the scans, but on pages added later. The Urdu scan of the 1941 book begins with a portrait captioned as Pandit Roop Chand Joshi, the originator of the Lal Kitab, and nothing on that page dates it. The Devanagari item cited by Wikipedia opens with a Hindi foreword from a group calling itself AstroStudents, which also credits him with all five books. Something of the uncertainty Wikipedia mentions shows here: the printed title pages carry a publisher’s name, and in these scans the credit to Joshi comes from pages added later. The inner pages of the books were not searched for an author’s name. No source read for this page explains the difference, so the page does not offer a reason.

The Five Editions, 1939 to 1952

The titles, years and page counts are Wikipedia’s. The last column lists the archive.org items that hold a scan of each, with the number of scanned images in brackets.

YearTitleIn EnglishPagesScans on archive.org
1939Lal Kitab Ke Farmanthe edicts of Lal Kitab383lal-kitab-1939_201909 (402); lal-kitab-1939_202006 (402)
1940Lal Kitab Ke Arman (Ilm Samudrik Kee Lal Kitab Ke Armaan)the aspirations of Lal Kitab280lal-kitab-1940 (76)
1941Gutka (Ilm Samudrik Kee Lal Kitab)the third part, a handbook428LALKITAB1941URDUEDITION (452); LalKitab1941 (521, Devanagari)
1942Lal Kitab Ke Farman (Lal Kitab – Tarmeem Shuda)the Farman again, marked as revised384LalKitab1942 (390)
1952Ilm-e Samudrik ki buniyad par ki Lalkitab (Lal Kitab)the Lal Kitab on the foundation of samudrik1173LalKitabEdition1952Part1Of3 (400); LalKitabEdition1952Part2Of3 (401); LalKitabEdition1952Part3Of3 (408); Pt.RoopChandLalKitab.11952 (98, Devanagari)

Together the five come to 2648 pages. The 1952 book alone has 1173 of them, about 44 per cent, which is more than the 1939 and 1942 books put together but less than the other four combined (1475).

How the Five Books Follow One Another

1939, the Farman. The first book’s title page calls it the Lal Kitab of samudrik, the old study of reading the body and the palm, after lines saying it is for drawing up a birth chart from the lines of the hand.

1940, the Armaan. The second book is the shortest, at 280 pages. In the scan its sections are headed Armaan number one, number two and so on, under the running title Lal Kitab ke Armaan.

1941, the third part. Wikipedia calls the third book the Gutka, a word for a small handbook, and describes it as the third part. The 2010 uploader calls it the Teesra Hissa, which means the same.

1942, the revised Farman. Wikipedia gives the fourth book the first one’s title again, Lal Kitab Ke Farman, and the scan’s title page marks the difference: printed small beside the words Lal Kitab is “tarmeem shuda”, Urdu for amended or revised. Its 384 pages make it nearly the same size as the 1939 book. Whether the revision changed much inside is not something this page has checked.

1952, the large final book. The last book carries an English line on its Urdu title page, “Astrology based on palmistry”, and its title builds on samudrik as well. On archive.org it is split into three items, LalKitabEdition1952Part1Of3, LalKitabEdition1952Part2Of3 and LalKitabEdition1952Part3Of3.

Lahore, Pharwala and a Correction

The 1942 title page lists the places where the book could be bought, Lahore among them, and its last line names a press in Lahore where it was printed. The 1952 title page names a press in New Delhi instead. Pharwala, the village on all of these pages, belongs to Jalandhar district, which is in India. Any account that places Pharwala in Pakistan is mistaken on that point; what the 1942 book connects with Lahore is its printing and its sale. One more Lahore claim, that the Lahore Museum keeps a copy of the 1939 book, carries a citation-needed tag on Wikipedia, and the page leaves it out.

What Is the Original Lal Kitab?

In the plainest sense it is these five Urdu books, printed between 1939 and 1952. Everything else that carries the name came later, and archive.org holds more than one kind.

First come Devanagari renderings of the Urdu text, for readers of Hindi. Two are in the table: the 1941 item already described, and an item whose cover reads “Lal Kitab 1952 in Hindi Volume-1” (Pt.RoopChandLalKitab.11952). They change the script, not the edition.

Then come new books by other people that use the name in their titles. On archive.org these include Asli Prachin Lal Kitab, credited to Girdhari Lal Sharma and Manohar Lal Sharma Vashisht (Lakshmi Prakashan, Delhi), Sampurna Lal Kitab aur Hastarekha Gyan, credited to Umesh Puri Gyaneshwar (Randhir Prakashan, Haridwar, 2010) and Arun Samhita Lal Kitab, credited to Dr Arun (Hare Krishna Trust, Chandigarh, 1999). The Girdhari Lal Sharma of the first title shares a name with the publisher of the Urdu books; nothing read for this page shows whether the two are one man. Wikipedia’s reading list adds books in English by R.S. Chillar (Sagar Publications, 2004), U.C. Mahajan (Pustak Mahal, 2004) and Radhakrishan Srimali (Diamond Pocket Books, 2007). All of these came out after 1952, and none of them is one of the five editions.

What Language Was Lal Kitab Written In?

Every title page this page looked at is printed in Urdu script, from 1939 to 1952, and the 2010 uploader says all five books were in Urdu. Wikipedia’s opening sentence words it another way, as books written in Hindi and later in the Urdu script too. The scans side with the uploader on the script. The Hindi most readers know comes from the later Devanagari versions described above.

Seeing the Scans

Each archive.org item named in the table can be found by putting its name after archive.org/details/ in a browser. The numbers in brackets were read from each item’s scan record on 4 November 2026; they count scanned images, covers and added pages included, not printed pages. They should not be read as a check on completeness. The three 1952 parts hold 1209 images against Wikipedia’s 1173 pages, while in the 1940 item at least one image shows four printed pages at once, so its 76 images say little about how many of the 280 pages it holds.

Lal Kitab Beside the Sanskrit Texts

The Lal Kitab is a twentieth-century book in Urdu, so it belongs to a different shelf from the Sanskrit works the site reads verse by verse. Those are filed on the three skandhas page, and the short Laghu Parashari is one of them. Because its title pages tie it to the reading of the hand, the site’s palmistry guide is the nearer neighbour.

Related Pages

The remedies that carry the book’s name are described on the Lal Kitab remedies guide and the Lal Kitab totke page, each with its own caveats. In Hindi: लाल किताब किसने लिखी? पंडित रूप चंद जोशी और 5 संस्करण.

Begin With Your Own Birth Details

The free kundli tool works out your lagna, Moon sign, nakshatra and the Vimshottari dasha running now. It follows the usual Vedic reckoning; it does not apply the Lal Kitab’s rules and it prescribes nothing.

Find My Lagna and Nakshatra