Skip to main content
Live Pandit Ji
LIVE

the classical texts

Prashna Tantra by Neelakanta: Chapters and Sources

Published 2026-11-04 | Live Pandit Ji

In horary astrology a question is answered from a chart cast for the moment it is asked, not from the birth chart of the person asking. Prashna Tantra (प्रश्नतन्त्र), often spelled Prasna Tantra, is a compact Sanskrit manual of that method, credited to Neelakanta Daivajna and written in the Tajaka idiom of applying and separating aspects. The version read for this page is B. V. Raman’s English translation with notes, the second edition from Raman Publications, Bangalore; his general introduction is dated 1969 and the preface to this edition 1972. What follows covers the question of whether the book stands alone, its author and date as Raman gives them, its four chapters section by section, the stanzas Raman traces to older books, and the aspect rules that close it. No question is answered here, and the site makes no claim that the method works.

A Third Tantra, or a Book of Its Own?

Raman’s introduction raises the question itself. Some authorities, he reports, do not count this as an independent work at all but as the third and last division of Neelakanta’s larger Tajaka book, coming after a Samjna Tantra of definitions and a Varsha Tantra on the annual chart. He leaves the matter open and says the book is worth reading either way for how plainly it treats its subject. He also records that the first two divisions carry commentaries by one Viswanatha Daivajna, while no commentary was written on the third.

The site’s Tajika Nilakanthi page meets the same question from another edition. There the 1907 Mumbai print with Mahidhara’s Hindi gloss does bind in a prashna tantra, but Mahidhara writes that Neelakanta’s own third part is hard to find and survives incomplete, and that what he prints is a collection made by earlier authors. Raman’s notes lean the same way for his text: as the table further down shows, they send fifty-one stanzas back to five older books or authors. Whether Raman’s Sanskrit and Mahidhara’s prashna part are one text has not been checked here.

The Author’s Family, and a Date Converted Wrongly

Raman draws the author’s background from the Tajaka itself and from what he calls collateral sources. In his account Neelakanta came from a family of astrologers: the grandson of Chintamani Daivajna, the son of Ananta Daivajna and the brother of Rama Daivajna, of the Gargya gotra. He adds that Neelakanta hailed from Vidarbha and was about 43 or 44 years old when he wrote. The grandfather and father match the closing verses that the Tajika Nilakanthi page reads. Separately, the Muhurta Chintamani page reads that book’s author, Rama, as Ananta’s son and the younger brother of a learned Nilakantha; the link between the two books is Raman’s statement, and this page does not test it.

For the date, Raman points to the end of the Varsha Tantra, where Neelakanta records that he finished on the eighth of the bright fortnight of Ashvina in Shaka 1509. Raman then writes that this means 1567 A.D. The conversion does not hold. The Shaka count runs 78 years behind the Common Era, so Ashvina of Shaka 1509 falls in 1587, twenty years later than his figure, and 1587 is also the year the Tajika Nilakanthi page derives from the same verse. This page follows 1587 and reports 1567 as Raman’s printed figure. The verse dates the Varsha Tantra; whether it also dates the prashna part depends on the question in the section above.

Four Chapters, and How Raman Numbers the Stanzas

Raman’s introduction names the four chapters with their Sanskrit titles. The headings over them in his translation are partly English, and his stanza numbers restart more than once, so the table gives each numbered run separately.

Ch.Sanskrit nameHeading in the translationStanza runs
1Prasna Vichara (preliminaries)Uses of Horary Astrology1 to 5; then 1 to 30
2Bhava Prasna (questions by house)Bhava Prasna1 to 13; then 1 to 130
3Visesha Prasna (special questions)On Special Questions1 to 191
4Prakirnakadhyaya (miscellaneous matters)Miscellaneous Matters1 to 61

Chapter 1 numbers its first five stanzas, then starts again at the section on the querist and runs to 30. Chapter 2 counts thirteen stanzas of general rules, then numbers its house questions afresh from 1 to 130. Chapter 3 runs straight through from 1 to 191, the longest single run, and chapter 4 goes from 1 to 61, where the text ends. These are the last numbers printed in each run, read from a noisy scan; they are not a tally of verses, and the page gives no total for the book. A printed slip in the scan explains one oddity: the page on which chapter 3 begins was bound after a later page, so its opening stanzas appear before the chapter heading.

Section by Section

The contents pages in the scan list only chapters 1 and 2; the rows for chapters 3 and 4 come from the headings printed in the body. The headings are Raman’s and the descriptions are this page’s. In chapter 4 one run of stanzas carries no heading, so it appears in brackets, and one heading in chapter 3 is given in a neutral paraphrase rather than as printed. The twenty-nine rows marked title only deal with illness, children, missing persons, theft, quarrels, war, money, trade, crops, dreams, hunting and intimacy; they are named and nothing more, and the site prints none of their rules or results. Nothing is relayed from the other rows of chapters 2 to 4 either, apart from the aspect definitions discussed below.

Ch.Sections
1

Uses of Horary Astrology: nine sections

  • Uses of horary astrology: why people ask, and the story of Brahma learning prashna from Vishnu
  • How to put a query: how the querist comes to the astrologer
  • The true astrologer: the learning the book asks of the astrologer
  • About the querist: whether the question is sincerely put
  • Answering more than one query: where each of several questions is read from
  • Planetary avasthas: the ten states of a planet
  • Results of avasthas: what each state is said to bring (title only)
  • Planetary indications: the seasons, directions and colours each planet stands for
  • Events to know from different houses: what each of the twelve houses covers
2

Bhava Prasna: seventeen sections

  • General estimate: how any bhava gets judged
  • Success of object in view: whether the matter asked about comes off
  • Malefic combinations: the yogas the chapter counts against success
  • First house questions: the querent's own past, present and future
  • Second house questions: money (title only)
  • Third house questions: brothers and sisters
  • Fourth house queries: land, cultivation and leases
  • Fifth house questions: children and pregnancy (title only)
  • Sixth house questions: illness and enemies (title only)
  • Employer-employee relations: service and a change of job
  • Seventh house questions: marriage, partners and disputes (title only)
  • Eighth house questions: matters the chapter files under the eighth house (title only)
  • Ninth house questions: the ninth house's matters
  • Tenth house questions: office, authority and work
  • On realising the object: whether, and through whom, a wish is fulfilled
  • Eleventh house questions: gains (title only)
  • Twelfth house questions: expense and opponents (title only)
3

On Special Questions: twenty sections

  • Return of a person in exile: a person who has left home (title only)
  • The absent traveller (paraphrased): an absent traveller's state; its later stanzas turn to an enemy's march (title only)
  • Attacking the fortress: a siege (title only)
  • On the recovery of the patient: illness (title only)
  • On the curse of deities: trouble the book ascribes to a deity's displeasure (title only)
  • Master-servant relations: how servant and master will get on
  • Future with another master: leaving one employer for another
  • Recovery of lost property: lost and stolen things (title only)
  • Identity of thief: the thief (title only)
  • Special rules regarding children: offspring and conception (title only)
  • On meals: what a meal will be
  • On dreams: what is seen in sleep (title only)
  • On sport: hunting (title only)
  • On disputes: quarrels and suits (title only)
  • On the traveller: a traveller's return (title only)
  • Release of the imprisoned traveller: a traveller held captive (title only)
  • Queries bearing on ships: vessels at sea (title only)
  • Truth of rumours: whether a report is true
  • On purchase and sale: buying and selling (title only)
  • On crops: the harvest (title only)
4

Miscellaneous Matters: thirteen sections

  • Miscellaneous matters: gain of money (title only)
  • General judgment of houses: how the houses are weighed together
  • On the time factor: when an event comes about (title only)
  • [no heading] What the question is about: letters of the alphabet, mineral, vegetable or living, and the person concerned
  • On sexual matters: intimacy (title only)
  • On trade and commerce: trade (title only)
  • On Tajaka aspects: the aspects and their orbs
  • Ithasala yoga: an applying aspect
  • Easarapha yoga: a separating aspect
  • Naktha yoga: light carried by a faster planet
  • Examples: a worked chart in the text, on a question about marriage (title only)
  • Yamaya yoga: light carried by a slower planet
  • Kamboola yoga: the Moon joining an ithasala

Raman himself remarks that the subjects are a little jumbled: marriage and children come up in chapter 2 under their houses and then again, at greater length, in chapter 3.

Before Any Chart Is Read

Chapter 1 begins with conduct. In Raman’s rendering of stanza 3, the person asking goes to a learned astrologer early in the morning, brings fruit, flowers and money, faces east, salutes him and puts a single question of an auspicious kind. The section on the querist then has the astrologer judge first, from the strength of the ascendant, whether the question is sincerely meant (stanza 1), and stanzas 2 to 4 list chart positions on either side; a malefic in the ascendant is among those counted against sincerity and a benefic there among those counted for it. The introduction adds Raman’s own gloss, that a question put lightly or with mischief in mind should be turned away. This is the book’s procedure as translated; the site does not claim a chart can show anyone’s intentions.

When several questions are put together, stanzas 5 and 6 assign each one a point of the chart to be read from:

  • the 1st question: the ascendant
  • the 2nd question: the Moon
  • the 3rd question: the Sun
  • the 4th question: Jupiter
  • the 5th question: the stronger of Mercury and Venus

Raman sets a limit of his own in the introduction. Some questions, he warns, could be used to harm someone, and he gives the examples of a question about an ailing parent and one about a spouse’s character; where the motive looks suspect, he says, the astrologer should not answer.

Stanza 7 asks the astrologer to weigh ten states of a planet, and Raman’s note names them: deeptha (exalted), deena (debilitated), muditha (in a friend's sign), swastha (in its own sign), suptha (in an enemy's sign), nipeeditha (beaten in planetary war), mushita (combust), pariheena (moving towards its debility), suveerya (moving towards its exaltation) and athiveerya (rich in benefic vargas). The site’s deeptadi avastha page works from Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra chapter 45, where the text counts nine states; the names overlap only in part. Stanzas 8 to 10 give each state’s result, and those are not repeated here. The chapter closes with the matters of the twelve houses, stanzas 19 to 30, where Raman notes one difference from the Parashari books: stanza 28 gives the father to the 10th house rather than the 9th.

Bhava Prashna: Every Question Goes to a House

Chapter 2 has twelve sections named after the houses, with two more on service and on whether a wish is fulfilled. Raman’s introduction sums up the logic they share. The ruler of the ascendant stands for the person asking, the ruler of the house that holds the subject stands for the matter, and planets in either house have a part as well. The outcome is read from whether and how those two rulers come into aspect. Houses can be counted from other houses: in his example a question about a brother’s wife goes to the 9th, which is the 7th counted from the 3rd. Raman also says the house verses of this chapter are gathered from other Tajaka sources, Prasna Deepika among them. None of the chapter’s combinations is relayed here.

Stanzas Raman Traces to Older Books

In his notes Raman stops now and then to say that a stanza or a run of them comes from another work. The table lists every such note in which the book’s name and the stanza numbers can both be read clearly in the scan; a few notes whose titles came out garbled are left out. The section is the one the note falls under.

Ch.StanzasSource Raman namesSection
21 and 2 (opening run)ShatpanchasikaGeneral estimate
29 to 12 (house run)Prasna DeepikaSecond house questions
310 to 30Prasna ChintamaniReturn of a person in exile
385 and 86ShatpanchasikaRecovery of lost property
3123 to 126Prasna ChintamaniSpecial rules regarding children
3148BhattotpalaOn dreams
3153 to 156Bhuvana DeepikaOn disputes
3157 to 160Bhuvana DeepikaOn the traveller
425 and 26Shatpanchasika[no heading]
427 to 29Utpala[no heading]
431 to 34Shatpanchasika[no heading]

Together these come to fifty-one stanzas. The Shatpanchasika accounts for ten of them, spread over chapters 2, 3 and 4; it is the short prashna book by Prithuyasas that has its own Shatpanchashika page here. Raman names Bhattotpala in one note and Utpala in another, and the count of five treats them as one. None of these attributions has been checked against the books named.

Tajaka Aspects, Orbs and Yogas in Chapter 4

The last stanzas of the book turn from questions to tools. Stanzas 49 to 53 deal with aspects as the Tajaka counts them. In stanza 52 the general orb for every aspect is 12 degrees, and stanza 53 then gives each planet a special orb of its own, the deeptamsa. Raman’s introduction lists the same orbs, with one figure different:

PlanetStanza 53 (degrees)Raman’s introduction (degrees)
The Sun1515
The Moon1212
Mars87 (differs)
Mercury77
Jupiter99
Venus77
Saturn99

For Mars the stanza has 8 and the introduction 7. The figures of stanza 53 are the ones the site’s ithasala page takes from another translation, so the odd one out is the introduction’s.

The remaining stanzas define the yogas that the aspects form, each under its own heading: Ithasala (stanzas 54 and 55), Easarapha (stanza 56), Naktha (stanza 57), Yamaya (stanza 60) and Kamboola (stanza 61). In plain terms, Ithasala names an aspect still closing, Easarapha one already parting, Naktha and Yamaya the cases where a third planet carries the light between two that do not aspect each other, and Kamboola the Moon joining an Ithasala. Raman calls the carrying of light translation of light and explains it in his introduction. Kamboola, in stanza 61, is the last stanza; the translation marks the end of the Prasna Tantra right after it. The site’s Tajik yogas page sets out these yogas and the rest of the Tajaka list from the varshphal side. Raman then adds his own worked examples, twelve by his count, which belong to him rather than to the text and are not relayed.

How It Differs From Prashna Marga

Raman translated both books, and in this introduction he calls Prashna Marga the fullest exposition of horary, his own translation of it then still to come. The contrast is one of scale and method. Prashna Marga runs to 32 chapters and builds its answer from a ritual and the arudha, the sign where the querist stands; Prashna Tantra fits into four and works from the rising sign, the house rulers and Tajaka aspects with their orbs. The Daivajna Vallabha page covers a third prashna manual for comparison.

What the Page Leaves Out

No rule or result from chapters 2, 3 or 4 is given, beyond the definitions of the aspects and yogas. The twenty-nine title-only sections appear by name alone, and the page says nothing about anyone’s health, family, money, travel or dispute. The results of the planetary states in chapter 1, the timing methods of chapter 4 and the timing notes in Raman’s introduction are left out, and so are his worked examples. No Sanskrit is quoted, because the verses did not survive the scan’s text layer.

Related Pages

The three skandhas page places prashna within hora, the branch of jyotish that reads charts, and lists the classical texts the site covers. Within the Tajaka family, the Tajika Nilakanthi page maps Neelakanta’s book on the annual chart, and the ithasala and Tajik yogas pages carry the aspect rules further. For the Kerala approach to the same kind of question, see Prashna Marga; for the older short manual this book borrows from, the Shatpanchashika. In Hindi: नीलकंठ का प्रश्न तंत्र: अध्याय और स्रोत.

Where Was the Moon?

Raman’s introduction treats the Moon’s place in a question chart as a clue to what the person asking has in mind. The Moon sign calculator gives the sidereal sign and nakshatra of the Moon for a date, time and place you enter. It is built for birth details and gives no answer to a question.

Look Up the Moon’s Sign