Western technique
Accidental Dignities and Debilities: Lilly's Table
Published 2026-11-05 | Live Pandit Ji
On page 115 of Christian Astrology (1647), William Lilly prints what he calls “A ready Table whereby to examine the Fortitudes and Debilities of the Planets”. Its top half scores the essential dignities, the ones a planet has from the sign and degree it occupies. Its lower half, headed “Accidentall Fortitudes”, scores everything else Lilly counts: the house the planet stands in, how it moves, where it stands relative to the Sun, its exact aspects with four other planets and the nodes, and three fixed stars. This page types that lower half row by row, adds up what the rows allow, and follows Lilly through the one figure in which he scores all seven planets himself.
Essential and Accidental Dignity
The difference is what each one looks up. An essential dignity depends only on the planet’s tropical sign and degree, read against a fixed grid of houses, exaltations, triplicities, terms and faces, so two charts with the planet in the same degree give it the same essential score. Lilly’s grid and its points (5 for a planet in its own house down to 1 for its face) are set out on the essential dignities page. An accidental dignity depends on the particular figure: the same degree can sit in the 10th house of one chart and the 12th of another, and the planet can be swift on one day and retrograde a few weeks later. Lilly’s table keeps the two halves apart and gives both in the same unit, points, so they can be added.
The Lower Half of the Table, Row by Row
The machine-read text of the scan turns the planet glyphs and most digits of this table into noise, so every row and score below was read off the page image of the Wellcome Library copy on archive.org. The left column has eighteen fortitude lines and the right column fifteen debility lines. The labels here are plain English; where a row names planets by glyph, they are spelled out.
| Accidental fortitude | Points | Can apply to |
|---|---|---|
| In the Mid-heaven or the Ascendant | 5 | any planet |
| In the 7th, 4th or 11th house | 4 | any planet |
| In the 2nd or 5th house | 3 | any planet |
| In the 9th house | 2 | any planet |
| In the 3rd house | 1 | any planet |
| Direct in motion (void for the Sun and Moon) | 4 | Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, Venus and Mercury |
| Swift in motion | 2 | any planet |
| Saturn, Jupiter or Mars oriental | 2 | Saturn, Jupiter and Mars |
| Mercury or Venus occidental | 2 | Mercury and Venus |
| The Moon increasing, or occidental | 2 | the Moon |
| Free from combustion and the Sun's beams | 5 | all but the Sun |
| Cazimi, in the heart of the Sun | 5 | all but the Sun |
| Partile conjunction with Jupiter or Venus | 5 | any planet |
| Partile conjunction with the Dragon's Head | 4 | any planet |
| Partile trine to Jupiter or Venus | 4 | any planet |
| Partile sextile to Jupiter or Venus | 3 | any planet |
| Conjunct Cor Leonis (Regulus), which Lilly puts in 24 Leo | 6 | any planet |
| Conjunct Spica, which Lilly puts in 18 Libra | 5 | any planet |
| Debility | Points | Can apply to |
|---|---|---|
| In the 12th house | 5 | any planet |
| In the 8th or 6th house | 2 | any planet |
| Retrograde | 5 | Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, Venus and Mercury |
| Slow in motion | 2 | any planet |
| Saturn, Jupiter or Mars occidental | 2 | Saturn, Jupiter and Mars |
| Venus or Mercury oriental | 2 | Venus and Mercury |
| The Moon decreasing in light | 2 | the Moon |
| Combust of the Sun | 5 | all but the Sun |
| Under the Sun's beams | 4 | all but the Sun |
| Partile conjunction with Saturn or Mars | 5 | any planet |
| Partile conjunction with the Dragon's Tail | 4 | any planet |
| Besieged of Saturn and Mars | 5 | Jupiter, the Sun, Venus, Mercury and the Moon |
| Partile opposition of Saturn or Mars | 4 | any planet |
| Partile square of Saturn or Mars | 3 | any planet |
| Conjunct Caput Algol, which Lilly puts in 20 Taurus, or within five degrees of it | 5 | any planet |
Lilly’s own note under the table, on the next page, is short: I forbeare here to explaine the Table, because I shall doe it better hereafter, upon some Example.
The example is the figure taken further down this page. The “Can apply to” column follows the wording of each row: the direct row says the Sun and Moon are alwayes so, as to them this is voyd
, the four rows about the Sun cannot apply to the Sun itself, and besieging by Saturn and Mars needs both of them to be other planets.
What the Rows Mean, in Lilly’s Words
- Houses. Every one of the twelve houses has exactly one row. Nine score as fortitudes, from 5 for the Mid-heaven and Ascendant down to 1 for the 3rd; the 6th, 8th and 12th are debilities, the 12th at 5, as heavy as a detriment.
- Direct, retrograde, swift, slow. On page 114 Lilly calls a planet direct when it moves forward in the sign, “as going out of 13. degr. into 14.”, and retrograde when it goes backward. Retrograde is one of the six debilities scored at 5, the largest figure on the debility side. Swift and slow are judged against the planet’s mean daily motion; in his worked figure he compares each planet’s motion that day with its mean before scoring it.
- Oriental and occidental. On the same page:
to be Orientall is no other thing then to rise before the
Sun, and to be occidental is to set after the Sun has gone down. Saturn, Jupiter and Mars are oriental from their conjunction with the Sun until their opposition; the Moon is occidental from her conjunction to her opposition. The table scores the pattern both ways at 2 points: the three outer planets gain when oriental, Mercury and Venus when occidental, the Moon when increasing, and each loses the same 2 in the opposite case. - The Sun. Four rows: free from combustion and the Sun’s beams (5), cazimi or “in the heart of the Sun” (5), combust (5) and under the beams (4). This page names those rows and their points only, and leaves out any distance for them and any account of where one state ends and the next begins.
- Partile aspects. On page 106 a partile aspect is one where two planets are
exactly so many degrees from each other as make a perfect aspect
. His examples: Venus in 9 degrees of Aries and Jupiter in 9 of Leo make a partile trine; the Sun in 1 degree of Taurus and the Moon in 1 of Cancer, a partile sextile. Both examples come out at 120 and 60 degrees, the same degree number in each sign. Only partile contacts score in this table; the wider “platick” aspects, measured by the planets’ orbs, have no row. - Besieged. Also on page 114: besieging
is, when any Planet is placed betwixt the bodies of the two Malevolent Planets
, Saturn and Mars. His example puts Saturn in 15 Aries, Mars in 10 and Venus in 13, so Venus sits between them, all three in one sign.
Adding Up the Columns
The fortitude column sums to 64 and the debility column to 55, but no planet can collect a whole column. Many rows rule each other out: a planet stands in one house, is either direct or retrograde, swift or slow, and is in only one of the four states relative to the Sun. Sorting the rows into ten such groups and taking the best row from each gives the most a single planet could collect. The aspect rows need care. Each needs its own planet, a planet never aspects itself, and a partile conjunction with Jupiter and a partile trine to Venus could in principle stand together, so the first count lets one aspect row to each of the two benefics (or malefics) stand together. Lilly does not say whether he meant two aspect rows to stack, so the second count allows only one.
| Planet | Most fortitude | Most debility | One aspect row a side |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saturn | 37 | 33 | 33 / 33 |
| Jupiter | 33 | 42 | 33 / 38 |
| Mars | 37 | 33 | 33 / 33 |
| The Sun | 26 | 30 | 22 / 26 |
| Venus | 33 | 42 | 33 / 38 |
| Mercury | 37 | 42 | 33 / 38 |
| The Moon | 33 | 37 | 29 / 33 |
The top fortitude, 37, belongs to Saturn, Mars and Mercury: each can use every group, including two benefics to aspect. Jupiter and Venus have only the other benefic to aspect, and the Moon has no direct row. The Sun has the lowest ceiling, because the direct row, the phase rows and the four Sun rows all pass it by. On the debility side Jupiter, Venus and Mercury reach 42; Saturn and Mars stay lower because each has only the other malefic to be afflicted by and neither can be besieged by the pair. The count tests the wording of the rows, not the sky: it does not check, for instance, whether a planet can be cazimi while Venus stands in partile trine to it.
Set beside the essential half, the scale is different. The essential rows add to 15 if a planet held all five dignities at once, and the dignities page shows that the grid never allows that. The worst essential case is 14, Mercury in Pisces, in detriment and fall at once and peregrine outside its own term. Lilly’s accidental ceiling of 37 is more than twice the essential one, so in his arithmetic the figure in front of the astrologer can outweigh the sign.
Lilly’s Worked Figure
The promised example comes in Book II, Chap. XXVIII, “If the Querent shall be Rich or Poore”, pages 178 to 180. Lilly says he will examine the planets by the Table of essentiall dignities Page 104. and the other Table of Page 115
, and that he does it that young Learners may better understand the use of both these Tables
. Each planet gets two lists with a printed total under each. The table below copies them, read off the images, with the essential rows (own house, exaltation, detriment, peregrine) mixed in as he mixes them.
| Planet | Fortitudes he lists | Debilities he lists | Net, as he prints it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Saturn | In the 3rd house 1; Free from combustion 5 (total 6) | Peregrine 5; Retrograde 5; Slow in motion 2; Occidental 2 (total 14) | -8 |
| Jupiter | In his exaltation 4; In the 10th house 5; Direct 4; Swift in motion 2; Free from combustion 5 (total 20) | none (total 0) | +20 |
| Mars | In the 1st house 5; Direct 4; Swift in motion 2; Free from combustion 5; Conjunct Spica 5 (total 21) | In his detriment 5; Peregrine 5; Occidental 2 (total 12) | +9 |
| The Sun | In his own house 5; In the 10th house 5 (total 10) | Slow in motion 2 (total 2) | +8 |
| Venus | In the 11th house 4; Direct 4; Swift in motion 2; Occidental 2; Free from combustion 5; Conjunct Regulus 6 (total 23) | Peregrine 5 (total 5) | +18 |
| Mercury | In the 10th house 5; Direct 4; Swift in motion 2; Occidental 2; Free from combustion 5 (total 18) | Peregrine 5 (total 5) | +13 |
| The Moon | In the 10th house 5; Increasing in light 2; Free from combustion 5 (total 12) | Slow in motion 2; Peregrine 5 (total 7) | +5 |
His rule for combining the lists, on page 181: having substracted the lesser number from the greater, make use of what remaines, whether they be Fortitudes or Debilities
. Every one of his fourteen lists adds up to the total he prints under it, every point he gives matches the ready table, and every net in his summary, “The Testimonies of all the Planets collected into one”, is the difference of the two. Only Saturn comes out on the debility side, at 8; Jupiter has the largest net, 20, and also the only empty debility list.
Three things in the figure are worth noticing. First, the accidental half carries the arithmetic: of the 110 fortitude points across all seven lists only 9 are essential (Jupiter’s exaltation and the Sun’s own house), while on the debility side 30 of the 45 points are, almost all of them for being peregrine (Saturn, Mars, Venus, Mercury and the Moon). Second, Lilly checks a planet against the grid before scoring it. Saturn, he writes, has no essential dignity in that degree
of Sagittarius where he stands, and his p.104 grid agrees for that degree by day and by night. Third, an aspect that is not partile gets nothing. Jupiter, he says, has no debilities, yet some Detriment it is unto him, being in
square with Mars, though the aspect be Platick
, and the square adds nothing to his list.
One entry does not follow his own grid. The Sun is In his owne House
, which for the Sun can only be Leo, and In Mid-heaven
, above the earth, so the figure is a day figure. The p.104 grid gives the fiery triplicity to the Sun by day, which would add 3 points and make the Sun’s net 11 instead of 8. His list does not carry the row. This page reports the gap and leaves his printed total as it stands. The same summary also scores the Part of Fortune: 5 debilities from its sign, and only 3 in its favour from the 2nd house, which leaves it weak by 2.
What Lilly then concludes about the querent’s estate is a horary judgement on one querent’s question. This page does not relay it, and the scores above are his bookkeeping, not a verdict on any reader’s planets.
The Three Fixed-Star Rows
Lilly gives each star in his table a tropical degree for his own time: Cor Leonis, the star now usually called Regulus, in 24 Leo, scored at 6, the single highest figure in the fortitude column; Spica in 18 Libra at 5; and Caput Algol in 20 Taurus or within five degrees
as a debility of 5. In his worked figure Venus collects the Cor Leonis row and Mars the Spica row. This page relays the rows as scoring rows only, and none of the lore that later writers attach to these stars.
The stars do not stay at Lilly’s degrees. Against the zodiac of the equinoxes they drift forward by about a degree every 71 or 72 years, on the rates in the site’s fixed-star table. That table’s 2026 positions sit 6, 6 and 7 degrees past the figures Lilly printed for Regulus, Spica and Algol, 379 years on. Carried back at the same rates to 1647, each star lands in the sign Lilly names, a little more than a degree past his whole-degree figure at most. Regulus has since crossed into tropical Virgo; the table first shows it there in 2012, so a Cor Leonis conjunction in a modern chart is no longer in Leo at all. Anyone using these rows should take the star’s current position, not Lilly’s.
Al-Biruni’s Lists, Six Centuries Earlier
The Book of Instruction that al-Biruni wrote in 1029, in R. Ramsay Wright’s 1934 translation, has no points, but it lists most of the same conditions. Section 512 gives the state in which a planet is at the height of its power
and then the reverse, ending this is the acme of weakness
. Matched condition by condition, every row of Lilly’s table has a counterpart there except ten: the 2nd, 5th, 9th and 3rd houses (al-Biruni speaks of the angles and of unlucky houses, not of these), the Moon’s increase and decrease, cazimi and combustion as separate rows, Venus and Mercury oriental, and the two nodes. In the other direction, three of his conditions have no row in Lilly: being in aspect to both Sun and Moon while they are in a fortunate state; having an increasing north latitude; and standing at the nadir of their joys.
On besieging, section 500 is wider than Lilly. A planet is besieged when the signs on either side of its own hold others, when it stands between two others inside one sign (corporally
besieged, which is the form of Lilly’s Aries example), or by the rays
, with a sextile or square in front of it and another behind. He then says that between two infortunes the influences are extremely bad
and between two fortunes extremely good
. Section 512 also counts being besieged by the fortunes among the strengths. Lilly’s table has a debility for besieging by Saturn and Mars and no fortitude for besieging by Jupiter and Venus.
Section 499 grades the houses: the angles a happy mean, the succedent houses past the half-way line, the cadent ones adversity, and among the cadents it separates the 3rd and 9th from the 6th and 12th, which are not only cadent but are also inconjunct to the horoscope
. Lilly’s scores split the cadents in the same place: the 3rd and 9th score as fortitudes, the 6th and 12th as debilities. His succedent houses are less even (2nd +3, 5th +3, 8th -2 and 11th +4), and his named angles, the 4th and 7th, score 4, a point below the Ascendant and Mid-heaven. The planetary joys do not follow these scores either: Mars has its joy in the 6th and Saturn has its joy in the 12th, both of them debility houses in the ready table.
Beside Shadbala
Parashari jyotish has its own strength arithmetic, shadbala, counted in virupas rather than Lilly’s points, in sidereal signs, and the two cannot be converted into each other. Three of its parts look at things Lilly’s lower half also looks at. Sthana bala is positional strength from sign, varga and house class; dig bala gives each graha a house of directional strength, and all of those houses are angles, which Lilly scores at 5 or 4 (5 for the digbala houses of Jupiter, Mars, the Sun and Mercury, 4 for those of Saturn, Venus and the Moon). Cheshta bala is motional strength, and there the two systems point opposite ways: vakra, retrograde motion, takes the full 60 virupas in the BPHS motion list, while Lilly scores retrograde as a 5-point debility. The vakri grah page covers how jyotish texts read retrogression. This page does not rank one scheme over the other.
Tropical Signs, and No Calculator
Lilly works in the tropical zodiac, so his star degrees and the essential half belong to a tropical chart, and his day-figure triplicities depend on sect. A kundli places the same planets in sidereal signs, which shifts the essential half but not the house, motion or aspect rows; the ayanamsa page explains the shift, and this page types no figure for it. There is no accidental-dignity calculator here. The table lets a reader score a planet by hand: take its house, motion, phase, state relative to the Sun, exact aspects and any star contact from a tropical chart, add the rows that apply, do the same for the essential half, and subtract as Lilly does. The total is his bookkeeping; it is not a reading, and this page gives none.
In Short
- Source: Lilly, Christian Astrology (1647), the ready table on page 115 and the worked figure in Book II, Chap. XXVIII, read off the page images
- Rows: 18 accidental fortitudes summing to 64, 15 debilities summing to 55
- Ceiling for one planet: 37 fortitude and 42 debility by the wording of the rows, against 15 for the essential half
- His worked figure: every total and net checks; the Sun’s day triplicity is the one row his own grid would add
- Fixed stars: Lilly’s 1647 degrees are now 6, 6 and 7 degrees out
- Al-Biruni: the same conditions without points; besieging between fortunes counts as a strength in his lists
Score the Essential Half Too
Lilly’s worked figure adds both halves of the ready table. His grid of houses, exaltations, triplicities, terms and faces, with its points and the peregrine rule, is on the essential dignities page. It is bookkeeping by hand, not a reading.
Open the Dignities Table