English astrology books
Vivian Robson's Electional Astrology (1937): Contents
Published 2026-11-05 | Live Pandit Ji
Electional astrology is the Western name for picking the moment to start something, and in 1937 Vivian E. Robson gave it a book of its own, printed by J. B. Lippincott Company with Philadelphia and London on the title page. In Indian terms the subject is muhurta. This page walks through the book from its contents page: how its twenty chapters are grouped, what Robson tells the reader to weigh first, how his chapter on planetary hours lines up with the hora table this site already prints, and where his method parts from the Muhurta Chintamani’s. Robson writes in the tropical zodiac of Western astrology, so his signs are not the signs of a kundli, and the book is not one of the jyotish texts the site reads elsewhere. Nothing below is a rule for anyone to follow, and no day or hour on this page is named as a good one.
The Author and the Claim in His Preface
The title page gives the author as Vivian E. Robson, B.Sc., and the leaf before it lists five books under his name, this one first; the others are The Radix System, A Beginner's Guide to Practical Astrology, A Students' Text-Book of Astrology and The Fixed Stars and Constellations in Astrology. The book offers nothing else about his life, and this page adds nothing to it. The last of those titles, his handbook of the stars, is read chapter by chapter elsewhere on the site.
The preface opens with a large claim. Robson says he is filling a gap, since “no book on Electional Astrology has ever before been published”, and that the subject, much studied up to the seventeenth century, had been left out of the revival of astrology in his own day. He also says he has gathered all the information available, ancient and modern. Both claims are the author’s; the site has not checked them against earlier catalogues. What the site can show is how thinly two older works it has read, one Greek and one English, treat the subject. Ptolemy’s Centiloquium, as the site tags it, gives eleven of its aphorisms to choosing a time, and William Lilly’s Christian Astrology dismisses elections in one sentence. The preface also tells the reader to come able to erect a chart, and promises that every technical term is explained in the glossary at the back.
Twenty Chapters in Three Groups
The contents page lists twenty chapters, then the glossary on page 203 and the index on page 225. Read down it and the plan is clear. Chapter I is an introduction. Chapters II to V hold the method, pages 21 to 64: general principles, the Moon, the lunar mansions and aspects, and the planetary hours. Chapters VI to XX, pages 65 to 202, apply that method to one kind of undertaking after another, from cutting the hair to launching a ship. The subject chapters take 138 pages against the method’s 44, and by the contents page’s numbers the longest single chapter is chapter XIII, Houses and Property, at sixteen pages. The glossary alone runs to twenty-two pages.
The page numbers below are the contents page’s, checked on the scan’s image because the text layer misreads several of them. The site’s code stores each row with the line of the scanned text where its heading appears in the body, and the build stops if the chapters skip a number or the pages run backwards. The descriptions are the site’s. Six chapters are marked subject only: Commerce and Finance (VIII), Medical Elections (XI), Marriage and Children (XII), Games and Sports (XV), Wars, Fights, and Lawsuits (XVI) and Prisoners and Criminals (XIX). For those the site names the subject and prints none of the rules.
| Ch. | Page | Heading | What it covers |
|---|---|---|---|
| I | 11 | Introduction | What an election is, how it reverses a horary figure, and its classes: radical, mundane and ephemeral |
| II | 21 | General Principles | Choosing the significators, the signs for speed or permanence, and a general rule for each house from the second to the twelfth |
| III | 32 | The Moon in Electional Astrology | The Moon: her phase, her aspects, her sign and her house, and the ways the ancients counted her weakened |
| IV | 41 | The Lunar Mansions and Aspects | The lunar mansions and the Moon's aspects to each planet, given for completeness |
| V | 56 | Planetary Hours | The planetary hours: how the day and night are divided and which planet holds each hour |
| VI | 65 | Personal Elections | Personal matters such as cutting the hair, bathing and wearing new clothes |
| VII | 72 | Domestic Elections | The household: engaging servants, buying food and cooking, tools and household work |
| VIII | 80 | Commerce and Finance | Buying, selling, borrowing, lending and other money matters (subject only) |
| IX | 91 | Business and Occupation | Learning a trade, a science or music, taking up employment and making contracts |
| X | 97 | Friendship and Favour | Friendship, reconciliation, visits, clubs, presents and asking favours |
| XI | 106 | Medical Elections | Medical matters (subject only) |
| XII | 117 | Marriage and Children | Marriage and children (subject only) |
| XIII | 127 | Houses and Property | Building, wells and water, repairs, buying and renting houses and moving house |
| XIV | 143 | Journeys and Messages | Journeys, returning from them, sending messages and writing letters |
| XV | 155 | Games and Sports | Games, races, hunting and fishing (subject only) |
| XVI | 166 | Wars, Fights, and Lawsuits | Wars, fights and lawsuits, which the chapter treats under the same rules (subject only) |
| XVII | 176 | Agriculture and Gardening | Buying farm land, planting trees, felling wood and sowing |
| XVIII | 184 | Animals | Buying and keeping animals and birds |
| XIX | 189 | Prisoners and Criminals | Prisoners and criminals (subject only) |
| XX | 192 | Public Affairs | Public offices, coronations, building churches and cities, and ships |
Chapter I: A Horary Figure Run Backwards
Robson defines the subject through its neighbour. A horary figure, he explains, takes a start time fixed for practical reasons, treats it as the birth of the undertaking and reads the outcome from it; Robson adds that Carter calls such a chart an inceptional figure. An election turns that round. Instead of reading the chart a convenient time happens to produce, the astrologer looks through the days available, finds the chart wanted, and fits the start to it. In Robson’s description the work is to make the planets that rule the matter as strong as the sky allows, which he calls fortifying them, and to tuck the afflicting ones away where they do least harm. He admits that an ideal election is usually impossible inside a real time limit, and that one settles for a reasonable one.
He then sorts elections into three classes by what the chart is built on: radical, mundane and ephemeral or horary. A radical election starts from the birth chart of the person it is made for, and Robson treats that chart as decisive, quoting the 6th aphorism of Ptolemy’s Centiloquy: “It is advantageous to make choice of days and hours at a time well constituted by the nativity.” If the birth chart is against a venture, he writes, no election can rescue it. A mundane election also weighs charts for great conjunctions, ingresses and lunations; Robson reports those rules and adds that they are rarely used. The ephemeral or horary kind, built on the sky at the chosen moment alone, is the one he says is usually considered, and it is the subject of the rest of the book, with the birth chart kept in mind throughout.
Chapters II and III: The Moon Before Everything
The general principles begin with the significators, and Robson leaves no doubt about their order: “By far the most important significator in any and every election is the Moon”. After the Moon his list runs to three more: the ascendant and midheaven cusps with their lords; the house ruling the matter and the lord of its cusp; and any planet or sign with a general rulership over the matter. His examples are the Sun for business, Jupiter for money and Venus for love. Signs are chosen by element for the kind of work, so earthy signs for farming and watery ones for voyages, and by quality for how fast the matter should move: cardinal for a speedy conclusion, fixed for slowness or permanence and mutable for change, or a medium length of time. The chapter closes with a short general rule for each house from the second to the twelfth, eleven in all, which Robson warns are only general and change with the business in hand.
Chapter III is wholly about the Moon, in a fixed order of questions. First the phase: in Robson’s account an increasing Moon is essential wherever growth is wanted, while a few tasks such as clearing weeds call for a waning one. Next the Moon’s aspects, which he rates above her sign, preferring that she make no aspect at all to a malefic rather than a good one. Then her sign, and last her house: the house that rules the matter, or any angle except the ascendant, a place he calls very unfavourable for the Moon. Between these he sets out the list, credited to the ancient astrologers, of the ways the Moon is weakened. It has ten items:
- Close to the Sun, worse while applying
- In her fall in Scorpio
- Near her opposition to the Sun
- In conjunction, square or opposition with the malefics
- Near either of the Moon's nodes
- In the last degrees of a sign that holds a malefic
- In a cadent house, or in the stretch of the zodiac called the Via Combusta
- In Capricorn, her detriment, or in Aries or Libra, which the book says afflict her own sign, Cancer
- Slower than her average daily motion
- Void of course: making no aspect before she leaves her sign
The last item has a page of its own on this site: the void of course Moon page measures how long such stretches last and how often they come. The degree figures the book attaches to several of the items are left off here.
Chapter IV: Mansions for Completeness, and the Moon’s Aspects
Robson presents this chapter as an inheritance rather than a tool. The ancient writers, he says, listed the effects of the Moon in each lunar mansion and in each aspect, and he gives both “for the sake for completeness”, the book’s own wording. He goes on to say that how the mansions were really used has been almost entirely lost. The mansion list, with an Arabic name and a short note on what each favours, is left out here; the site prints none of its effects.
One detail of the chapter matters for any reader coming from jyotish. To place the first mansion, Robson separates a zodiac counted from the constellations from what he calls the zodiac of signs used in all astrological work, and cites an estimate by Dr. Vijaya-Raghavulu for the distance between their starting points. That second zodiac, tied to the seasons, is the tropical one, so every sign in this book belongs to it. The figure he gives is not repeated here; how the two reckonings drift apart is the subject of the ayanamsa page.
The aspect notes are organised more tidily. For each of Sun, Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn in turn the book takes the Moon’s conjunction, sextile, square, trine and opposition, which makes thirty short notes. Robson then adds notes of his own for Uranus and Neptune, good aspects and bad aspects only, four more, introducing them as additions to the ancient rules. He treats the whole method of picking a day by its lunar aspects with some scorn, calling it rough and ready, yet he grants it a certain value. Some Hindi kundlis print the same two bodies as Harshal and Varun, and the site’s Harshal and Varun page explains why Parashari jyotish leaves them out.
Chapter V Beside the Site’s Hora Table
On the planetary hours Robson is blunter than on anything else. He includes them, he says, not because they matter much but because they are so popular, calls the system “of no scientific value and of little practical reliability”, and allows its use only “in a supplementary way”, never in place of a properly made election. The mechanics he then sets out are the ones the site’s hora table uses, and the site’s code checks the two against each other rather than assuming they match.
- The day starts at local sunrise and the night at local sunset, and each is cut into twelve equal parts. The hora table makes the same cut, so its hours stretch and shrink with the season.
- The weekday rulers in Robson’s table, Sunday to Saturday, match the weekday lords stored in the site’s data one for one.
- The order of the hours, which Robson calls the Chaldean order, is Saturn, Jupiter, Mars, Sun, Venus, Mercury and Moon, read on the scan’s image because the text layer turns the planet symbols into stray letters. It is the order the site’s data holds.
- Robson’s own pieces agree with one another. Start his order at the Sun, as his Sunday example does, and count twenty-four hours: Sunday’s last hour falls to Mercury, and the next sunrise opens on the Moon, three places along. Repeating the step gives Sun, Moon, Mars, Mercury, Jupiter, Venus and Saturn, his weekday table in its own order.
The differences lie in what each page does with the sequence. Robson reports a variant used by some modern authorities that cuts the day at noon and the night at midnight, six parts on each side, and says the difference matters only where one hour changes to the next; the hora table keeps to the twelve equal parts. Robson notes that ready-made devices giving each hour’s start for various latitudes were on sale in his day; the hora table times its hours for New Delhi alone. Above all, Robson gives each planet’s hour a paragraph of things to begin or avoid in it, in the same Chaldean order, and some of those paragraphs reach into illness and medicine. The site prints none of that advice, and its hora page deliberately says what a hora is without saying what to do in one. Neither Robson nor the site’s table has any hour for Rahu or Ketu.
What Robson Weighs, and What a Muhurta Book Weighs
Laid side by side, Robson’s book and the Muhurta Chintamani are built alike. Leaving aside Robson’s introduction, each opens with four chapters of tools and then turns to the undertakings themselves: Robson’s fifteen subject chapters, Rama Daivajna’s nine prakaranas, running from the samskaras and marriage to journeys, building and entering a house. What fills the tool chapters is where they part.
The Muhurta Chintamani’s first chapter, as the site reads it, judges a moment by tithis and their lords, weekdays, nakshatras and yogas, which are properties of the day that a panchang prints. Robson’s method chapters judge a chart drawn for the chosen moment: the Moon’s phase, aspects, sign and house, the rising sign and its lord, and the house that rules the matter. Several of the same things are being weighed under different names. Robson’s phase of the Moon is what a tithi counts, since both measure the Moon’s distance from the Sun. In his method chapters the weekday enters only through the planetary hours, which he ranks low; the Indian book weighs the weekday itself in its first chapter. His lunar mansions sit in a single chapter given for completeness, while the Muhurta Chintamani gives the nakshatras a chapter of their own and returns to them in its chapters on marriage, journeys and entering a house.
Both books also tie the choice back to the person. Robson does it through the birth chart, which he puts before every other consideration. The Muhurta Chintamani gives its fourth chapter to transits counted from the birth Moon, and its chapters on marriage and on entering a house weigh the lagna as well. The site’s page on the best day to start new work draws the same line in its own terms, between what is true of a date for everyone and what depends on one person’s chart. This comparison is of method only; the site does not say which of the two systems is right, and the muhurat section applies only the Indian panchang filters.
The Subject Chapters
Each subject chapter is a run of short headed sections, one undertaking each, and most sections tell the reader which significators to fortify and where to place the Moon. The headings below are the book’s, a few from each chapter not marked subject only; their rules are not reproduced.
- VI, Personal Elections: Cutting the Hair, Bathing and Buying or Wearing New Clothes
- VII, Domestic Elections: Engaging Servants, Buying Food and Cooking and Household Work
- IX, Business and Occupation: Learning Any Trade or Occupation, Learning Music and Making Contracts
- X, Friendship and Favour: Reconciling People at Variance, Visiting and Giving or Sending Presents
- XIII, Houses and Property: For Building Houses, Digging Wells and Removing to Another House
- XIV, Journeys and Messages: Journeys, Returning from Journeys and Writing Letters
- XVII, Agriculture and Gardening: Planting Trees or Grafting, Felling or Cutting Wood and Planting and Sowing
- XVIII, Animals: Buying Animals and Buying Birds
- XX, Public Affairs: Coronations and Installations, Building Churches and Launching Ships
Several of these are undertakings the Muhurta Chintamani also times, and the site has a page on its verses for each: haircuts and nail cutting, new clothes, digging a well, sowing and planting and setting out on a journey. The Indian book gives journeys its chapter 11 and building its chapter 12, where Robson gives them chapter XIV and chapter XIII. The two books reach those undertakings by different measures, and this page names no date for any of them.
Two chapter openings say something about the book rather than about an election. Chapter XVI explains that lawsuits were meant to have a chapter of their own but are folded in with wars and fights, since in Robson’s view the same rules serve both. Chapter XX, on public offices, coronations and the building of cities and ships, admits that its rules are “of no practical use” while astrology lacks official standing, and keeps them for completeness. Chapter XI begins by saying that a proper treatment of its subject would need a medical expert; beyond that remark, the site relays nothing from it.
Not on This Page
No rule from the book is offered as advice, and no date, day or hour is called favourable for anything. The six subject-only chapters are named by heading alone. Also left out: the advice attached to each planetary hour, the mansion-by-mansion effects, the results the book gives for the Sun or the Moon rising with each planet, the degree figures in the list of the Moon’s weakenings and the estimate for the start of the mansion zodiac. No ayanamsa figure is given, no clock time is printed and there is nothing to download. The site’s panchang pages give the day’s tithi and nakshatra for New Delhi, which is the Indian half of the comparison above.
Robson’s Hour Sequence, Printed in Full
The hora table lists all twenty-four lords for each weekday in the Chaldean order that chapter V uses, and times the current day’s hours for New Delhi only. It names no hour as good or bad for any purpose.
See the 24-hour sequenceRelated Reading
- AstrologyVivian Robson Fixed Stars and Constellations Book
- AstrologyAdbhut Sagar Ballal Sen Book of Omens Chapters
- AstrologyAl Biruni Book of Instruction Art of Astrology
- AstrologyAlan Leo Astrology for All Book Contents
- AstrologyAlan Leo Esoteric Astrology Book
- AstrologyAlan Leo Key to Your Own Nativity Book